Eighteenth-century Depictions of Cincinnatus
At its inception in 1783, the Society of the Cincinnati took its name from the Roman general Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus. That the Society would look to ancient Rome for inspiration was hardly unusual; the culture of the classical world served as a foundation for American mores in the eighteenth century. As such, the Society’s collections hold many depictions of the Society’s namesake, demonstrating how prevalent the principles represented by Cincinnatus were in eighteenth-century American life. These collections illustrate the significance of Cincinnatus not only as the Society’s lodestar but also as what he represents in the context of early American history—an affirmation of a new nation’s values by linking them with the long respected principles of ancient Rome.
Who was Cincinnatus? A well-respected soldier and landowner from the patrician class, he served as consul in 460 BCE and as dictator in 458 and 439. Consuls were the chief military and civil magistrates in the Roman republic; two were elected annually to serve a year-long term. Dictators, on the other hand, were given absolute magistracy during military or domestic crises. Dictators were appointed to accomplish a particular task, usually to lead an army into battle, and were expected to resign once the task was completed.
During the reign of Caesar Augustus (63 BCE-14CE), the historians Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus used Cincinnatus in their works as an early model of civic virtue. In 458 BCE, Roman troops led by the consul L. Minucius Esquilinus were under siege by the Aequi tribe on Mount Algidus. According to Livy’s Ab Urbe Condita, Cincinnatus was called from his modest farm and appointed dictator, charged with the task of breaking the siege on Esquilinus. Within a fortnight Cincinnatus had assembled an army, defeated the Aequi, and surrendered his office, returning to his farm. Livy contrasted Cincinnatus with the cautionary tale of Appius Claudius, whose reign Livy saw as a historical example of excess and abuse of power. Read More<
In Roman Antiquities, Dionysius of Halicarnassus also used Cincinnatus as a model of Roman virtue: “The only reason, that induced me to relate all these particulars, was to let all the world see what kind of men the Roman magistrates were at that time; that they worked with their own hands, and were temperate; that they were not uneasy under innocent poverty; and were so far from aiming at regal power, that they refused it even when offered.” Dionysius next compared Cincinnatus to “the Romans of this age,” lamenting that they pursued “everything that is contrary to their maxims.”
Cincinnatus also represented the virtuous agrarian life. The philosopher and statesman Cicero chronicled the second dictatorship of Cincinnatus in Cato Maior de Senectute, written in 44 BCE. Late in life Cincinnatus was once again appointed dictator, this time to resolve the affair of Spurius Maelius, a wealthy plebian accused of inciting revolt. In his narrative, Cicero explicitly used the image of Cincinnatus at his plough to glorify the “rustic” virtues of the citizen-soldier: “In my opinion, indeed, I know not whether anyone can be more happy: and not only in the discharge of duty, because to the whole race of mankind the cultivation of land is beneficial; but also … that fullness and abundance of all things which are connected with the food of men.” The strong imagery used by Livy, Dionysius, and Cicero lent a mythical aura to their depictions of Cincinnatus; even as early as the Augustan Age, Cincinnatus appears larger than life.
Depictions of this well-known model of public servitude appeared in early modern Europe and, by the eighteenth century, in America. They employed easily identifiable traits, drawing from Livy, Cicero, and Dionysus of Halicarnassus. Cincinnatus is often shown at the moment he is approached on his farm by members of the Senate. In these scenes, he is usually at his plough wearing the working clothes of a farmer—in contrast to the purple-trimmed toga presented to him as a symbol of his office. Cincinnatus is frequently shown returning from his term of service, as seen in The Return of Cincinnatus, a late eighteenth-century allegorical painting in the Society’s collections attributed to Angelica Kaufmann. In this work women greet Cincinnatus bearing agricultural tools while a sagum, the red cloak worn by Roman soldiers, lies discarded on the ground, symbolizing the rejection of military power by Cincinnatus. Cincinnatus is also commonly depicted putting on his sandals, although this portrayal was attributed interchangeably to Cincinnatus, Jason, or Hermes. Few works show Cincinnatus in any settings other than the offer of dictatorship or the return home, emphasizing that his significance lies not in military victory but in humility and duty.
That Americans were deeply familiar with the story of Cincinnatus shows how classical history and philosophy permeated eighteenth-century American culture. Admittance to early American institutions of higher learning was largely based on an applicant’s knowledge of the classics; grammar schools tailored their curricula to meet this requirement. The educated elite were quite familiar with Livy and Cicero in the original Latin while retellings in English were accessible to even rural communities—communities that were becoming increasingly literate. For example, Cincinnatus was included as a model of “disinterestedness” in L. M. Stretch’s Beauties of History, a late eighteenth-century publication “for the instruction and entertainment of youth.” The Boston bookseller Henry Knox, who later served as chief of artillery during the Revolutionary War, stocked Oliver Goldsmith’s Roman History in which Cincinnatus appears. Here Goldsmith’s “only aim was to supply a concise, plain, and unaffected narrative of the rise and decline of a well known empire.” These examples demonstrate that classical ideals appealed not only to the intellectual leaders of the day but also to those living in more remote reaches of the colonies.
During a period in American history in which many educated individuals lived in rural settings, it is no wonder Cincinnatus captured the American imagination. Revolutionary leaders saw the agrarian ideals of hard work, frugality, duty, and autonomy as a moral and philosophical framework for their vision of the new republic; they drew parallels between Roman virtues of public servitude and agrarianism, and Americans’ own sacrifice for their country. As a farmer and commander-in-chief of the Continental Army, George Washington was uniquely equipped to serve as a contemporary embodiment of these ideals.
Washington’s image—that of a citizen–soldier who selflessly served his country before returning to his farm—so clearly recalled the values of Cincinnatus he was often referred to as the “American Cincinnatus” or the “Cincinnatus of the West” even before the founding of the Society of the Cincinnati. The resignation of his commission in 1783 drew parallels to the portraits of Cincinnatus by Livy and Cicero. John Trumbull and Charles Willson Peale, among others, expressed these parallels in artistic works, like Jean-Antoine Houdon’s full-length statue of Washington as Cincinnatus, a cast of which graces the front lawn of Anderson House. In Houdon’s statue, Washington leans against a fasces, a symbol of the Roman dictatorship, and at his back is a plough, another nod to Cincinnatus.
The resignation of Washington and the founding of the Society of the Cincinnati demonstrate how the virtues exemplified by Cincinnatus remained relevant after the war. Washington, the American Cincinnatus, served as the first president general of the Society. This fraternal organization of Continental Army and Navy officers and their French counterparts impressed upon the members in its founding document, the Institution, to follow the example of Cincinnatus “by returning to their citizenship.” In following the immutable principles set forth in the Institution, the Society’s founding members emulated Cincinnatus’s sense of duty and his role as the citizen-soldier.
Major Pierre L’Enfant was responsible for designing the emblems of the Society which prominently feature Cincinnatus. His design for a round medal depicts the call to the dictatorship and Cincinnatus’s return home. Although the medal was not struck in the early days of the Society, L’Enfant incorporated the design into both the diploma and the Eagle insignia of the Society. L’Enfant considered an insignia, rather than a medal, to be more fitting—in the tradition of European orders with which he was familiar. The Society’s insignia, known as the Eagle, features Cincinnatus leaving the farm and his return on either side of the Eagle, and the obverse includes the Society’s motto: Omnia relinquit servare rempublicam, “He gave up everything to serve the republic.” L’Enfant’s original designs for these emblems are preserved in the Society’s archives.
Cincinnatus, a model of civic service and agrarian virtue for ancient Rome, served a similar role in eighteenth-century America as intellectual leaders looked to the past to shape their vision for the new republic. While Washington was hailed as the American Cincinnatus, he was not the only one who endeavored to emulate that citizen-soldier of antiquity. Indeed, the plural usage in the Society’s name affirms that each member would strive for the ideals of service, hard work, and humility—a whole generation of Cincinnati setting an example for the new American republic. Read Less<